Congressional Republicans laced into PBS and NPR on Wednesday, accusing the nation’s greatest public media networks of institutional bias in a fiery listening to that represented the newest salvo towards the American press by shut allies of the Trump administration.
Consultant Marjorie Taylor Greene, the Georgia Republican who organized the listening to — which she known as “Anti-American Airwaves” — opened her remarks by deriding PBS and NPR as “radical left-wing echo chambers” that printed skewed information stories and indoctrinated youngsters with L.G.B.T.Q. programming.
The leaders of each PBS and NPR testified that these claims have been unfaithful, arguing that their stations served as an important supply of correct data and academic programming for hundreds of thousands of Individuals, even because the NPR chief government acknowledged regrets for posting important remarks about President Trump earlier than she joined the broadcaster.
Democratic committee members mocked the proceedings as a cynical excuse by Republicans to air a well-recognized checklist of grievances towards the information media. A number of Democrats tried to shift focus to the Trump administration, citing the revelation that high safety officers inadvertently included the editor of The Atlantic on a bunch chat planning a army operation.
Consultant Stephen Lynch, Democrat of Massachusetts, stated that Republican lawmakers would somewhat go after Massive Chook than President Trump. “If disgrace was nonetheless a factor, this listening to could be shameful,” he stated.
The listening to, organized by a brand new congressional subcommittee, Delivering on Authorities Effectivity, represented one other entrance in a unprecedented two months of unrelenting assaults on the information media led by the Trump administration and its allies.
The White Home has barred The Related Press from attending sure occasions, damaged custom by hand-selecting the media shops that may take part within the presidential press pool and sought to dismantle the federal company that oversees Voice of America. The Federal Communications Fee has questioned the objectivity of main information organizations and ordered an investigation into PBS and NPR.
Public broadcasters, and the federal funds that help them, have been focused by Republican lawmakers for many years. In 1969, Fred Rogers, the star of “Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood,” testified before Congress to protest cuts proposed by the Nixon administration.
On Wednesday, the chief executives of NPR and PBS defended their programming and their worth to listeners and viewers. They emphasised the group journalism that covers native sports activities groups and crop costs — typically in rural areas with few different broadcasters — and beloved youngsters’s reveals like “Clifford the Massive Purple Canine” and “Curious George.”
“There’s nothing extra American than PBS,” stated Paula Kerger, the chief government of PBS.
Ms. Greene took an adversarial stance from the beginning. She grilled Katherine Maher, the chief government of NPR, about social media posts that she had written earlier than she grew to become the chief of the general public radio community, during which she described Mr. Trump as a “racist” and “sociopath.” Ms. Maher stated that she regretted these posts and wouldn’t have written them in the present day. “They represented a time after I was reflecting on one thing that the president had stated somewhat than who he’s,” she stated.
Ms. Greene additionally repeated assertions that journalists from each broadcasters underplayed a narrative, in the course of the 2020 marketing campaign, concerning the contents of Hunter Biden’s laptop computer. Ms. Maher, who was not working NPR on the time, stated that “our present editorial management thinks that was a mistake, as do I.”
Republicans additionally cited the expertise of Uri Berliner, a veteran NPR enterprise editor who argued in an essay final yr that his group had turn out to be infused with liberal bias. The essay, printed by The Free Press, grew to become a rallying cry for conservatives desirous to strip the broadcaster of federal funds; Mr. Berliner later resigned.
Requested on Wednesday how he felt concerning the day’s listening to, Mr. Berliner replied: “I don’t imagine NPR must be defunded. However I feel it ought to flip down federal help and overtly acknowledge and embrace its progressive orientation.”
The listening to swung wildly between Democrats expressing ardent help for youngsters’s programming and darkish pronouncements by Republicans concerning the “propaganda” and “communist agenda” ostensibly espoused by public media, which Ms. Greene accused of “grooming youngsters.” However there have been moments of levity.
Consultant Greg Casar, a Texas Democrat, held up an indication that learn, “Fireplace Elon, Save Elmo,” referring to Elon Musk, the billionaire businessman who’s main Mr. Trump’s effort to shrink the scale of the federal authorities.
At one other level, Consultant Robert Garcia, a Democrat from California, sarcastically requested Ms. Kerger if Elmo was a member of the Communist Social gathering. (“Effectively, he’s a puppet,” she replied. “However no.”) Mr. Garcia additionally requested if Bert and Ernie, two characters on “Sesame Road” who reside collectively, have been a part of an “excessive gay agenda” and if Cookie Monster, the “Sesame Road” character, was “silencing pro-cookie voters.”
“Cookies are a typically meals,” Ms. Kerger responded.
Consultant James Comer, Republican of Kentucky, recalled relying in his youth on native public radio for information whereas working as a farmer in a rural district of his state. However in the present day, he stated, “I don’t even acknowledge NPR anymore.” He requested why public media deserved the identical stage of presidency funding given the plethora of digital information shops now out there to Individuals no matter the place they reside.
The federal government-backed Company for Public Broadcasting acquired $535 million in public funds for this yr; most of that cash is spent on public radio and TV stations throughout the nation, with a small portion of it going on to NPR and PBS. Ms. Maher stated that NPR produced “unbiased, nonpartisan, fact-based reporting” and that it had 43 million weekly customers across the nation. Ms. Kerger described PBS and its programming and native information protection as a part of the group cloth.
The Pew Analysis Heart said on Monday {that a} survey this month confirmed that 43 % of adults believed NPR and PBS ought to proceed to obtain federal funding; 24 % stated Congress ought to take away these funds; and 33 % stated they weren’t positive.
Towards the tip of the listening to, Consultant Ro Khanna, a Democrat from California, cited Mr. Rogers’s testimony earlier than Congress, arguing that high quality instructional programming was a trigger that ought to transcend political variations.
“Mr. Rogers understood what we’ve forgotten on this nation,” Mr. Khanna stated. “Some issues are extra precious than cash at a time the place a rustic is polarized. I want we had slightly extra empathy and caring, and that’s not a partisan difficulty.”
Robert Draper contributed reporting.
About The Author
